The Importance of Ethics and Philosophy for Engineers | WSP Skip to content
  • Who we are

    We exist to future proof our cities and environment.

    We change the landscape, helping societies thrive, and continually challenge the status quo, asking: “What if we can?”

    Read more
    Who we are
    • What We Stand For
    • Our Story
    • Corporate Responsibility
    • UK Leadership
    Corporate Responsibility
    • Communities
    • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity and Inclusion
    • Ethics and Integrity
    • Health and Safety
    • Sustainability
    • UK Policies
    Featured Content
    We value - Square

    Can we help societies thrive in a world we do not…

    We believe that for societies to thrive, we must all hold ourselves accountable for tomorrow. That…

  • What We Do

    We shape the communities of tomorrow and help society thrive.

    Our understanding of local, regional and national needs enables us to deliver solutions that better connect people with places, now and in the future.


    View All

    • Sectors
    • Services
    • Projects
    What We Do
    • Property and Buildings
    • Transport and Infrastructure
    • Environment
    • Water, Energy and Industry
    • Planning and Advisory
    Featured Content
    butterfly thn

    Protecting nature

    How can we safeguard our natural environment?

  • Insights

    Our experts offer compelling insights that provide new perspectives.

    Read inspiring articles that challenge the status quo by reframing current issues, sparking fresh ideas and conversations.

    View all
    Insights
    • Climate
    • Mobility
    • Places
    • Resources
    • Society
    • Technology
    Featured Content
    Emeka bnr

    Profiling our people – Emeka Okorocha, Technical…

    As our combined responsibility to design and build sustainable infrastructure is recognised and…

  • Careers

    Help us shape the future

    Join a collaborative team of experts that thrives on complex challenges and unconventional thinking.

    See more
    Careers
    • Early Career
    • Experienced Professionals
    • Why choose WSP
    • Job Opportunities
    Featured Content
    BNR_Careers_Why_Choose_WSP

    Why you should work for us

    Live a full life, enjoy the rewards you deserve and be part of a business that plans, manages and…

  • Who we are
    • What We Stand For
    • Our Story
    • Corporate Responsibility
      • Who we are
      • Accountable for Tomorrow
        • Communities
        • Corporate Governance
        • Diversity and Inclusion
        • Ethics and Integrity
        • Health and Safety
        • Sustainability
        • UK Policies
    • UK Leadership
  • What We Do
    • Property and Buildings
    • Transport and Infrastructure
    • Environment
    • Water, Energy and Industry
    • Planning and Advisory
  • Insights
    • Climate
    • Mobility
    • Places
    • Resources
    • Society
    • Technology
  • Careers
    • Early Career
    • Experienced Professionals
    • Why choose WSP
    • Job Opportunities
Back

We are locally dedicated with international scale.

United Kingdom - English

International

  • Global
    English - Français

Americas

  • Canada
    English - Français
  • Chile
    Español
  • Colombia
    Español
  • Mexico
    Español
  • Panama
    Español
  • Peru
    Español
  • United States
    English

Africa

  • South Africa
    English

Asia

  • China
    中文(简体) - English
  • Hong Kong
    English
  • India
    English
  • Malaysia
    English
  • Philippines
    English
  • Singapore
    English
  • South Korea
    한국어(대한민국) - English
  • Thailand
    English

Europe

  • Denmark
    Dansk
  • Finland
    Suomi
  • France
    Français
  • Germany
    Deutsch
  • Greenland
    Kalaallisut - English
  • Netherlands
    Nederlands
  • Norway
    Norsk
  • Poland
    Polski - English
  • Romania
    English
  • Spain
    Español
  • Sweden
    Svenska - English
  • Switzerland
    Deutsch - English
  • United Kingdom
    English

Middle East

  • Kuwait
    English
  • Oman
    English
  • Qatar
    English
  • Saudi Arabia
    English
  • United Arab Emirates
    English

Oceania

  • Australia
    English
  • New Zealand
    English
Worldwide Offices
    • Investors

      Discover our diverse business, financial results and strategic ambitions.

      We are committed to delivering sustainable value to our shareholders and exceptional professional services to our clients.

      Read more
      Investors
      • Corporate Governance
      • Press Releases
      • Reports & Filings
      • Stock Information
      • Shareholder Information
      • Presentations and Events
      Corporate Governance
      • Audit Committee
      • Board of Directors
      • Business Conduct Hotline
      • Constating Documents
      • Governance Documents
      • Governance Ethics and Compensation Committee
      • Mandates
      Reports & Filings
      • AIF
      • Annual
      • Information Circular
      • Quarterly
      • SEDAR Filings
      • Sustainability
      Stock Information
      • Analyst Coverage
      Shareholder Information
      • Acquisitions
      • Dividends
      • Drip
      • FAQ
      Featured Content
      Thn-Web-Q42020-Results

      WSP's Q4 and 2020 Results

      We released our 2020 fourth quarter and fiscal results on February 24, 2021 after market close.

    • Investors
      • Corporate Governance
        • Investors
        • Corporate Governance
          • Audit Committee
          • Board of Directors
          • Business Conduct Hotline
          • Constating Documents
          • Governance Documents
          • Governance Ethics and Compensation Committee
          • Mandates
      • Press Releases
      • Reports & Filings
        • Investors
        • REPORTS & FILINGS
          • AIF
          • Annual
          • Information Circular
          • Quarterly
          • SEDAR Filings
          • Sustainability
      • Stock Information
        • Investors
        • Stock Information
          • Analyst Coverage
      • Shareholder Information
        • Investors
        • Shareholder Information
          • Acquisitions
          • Dividends
          • Drip
          • FAQ
      • Presentations and Events
    • News

      Progress happens quickly.

      Stay up to date with our projects, news, events and more.

      News
      • Latest News
      • Press Releases
      Featured Content
      Zero carbon photo 1920 x 750

      WSP to provide UK Government with technical advice…

      WSP will support the design of CCUS work programme and will advise BEIS on how to…

    • Contact us

      We are dedicated to our local communities and driven by global talent.

      We solve problems for our clients and the communities we serve, meeting the needs of today and tomorrow’s challenges. Contact us to find out how we…


      Follow us

      Contact us
      • Send a Message
      • Offices
      Featured Content
      Going net zero wind turbine 563 x 220

      Solutions for a net zero carbon future

      With the UK committed to a Clean Growth Strategy and becoming the first major economy to commit to a…

    • Investors

      Discover our diverse business, financial results and strategic ambitions.

      We are committed to delivering sustainable value to our shareholders and exceptional professional services to our clients.

      Read more
      Investors
      • Corporate Governance
      • Press Releases
      • Reports & Filings
      • Stock Information
      • Shareholder Information
      • Presentations and Events
      Corporate Governance
      • Audit Committee
      • Board of Directors
      • Business Conduct Hotline
      • Constating Documents
      • Governance Documents
      • Governance Ethics and Compensation Committee
      • Mandates
      Reports & Filings
      • AIF
      • Annual
      • Information Circular
      • Quarterly
      • SEDAR Filings
      • Sustainability
      Stock Information
      • Analyst Coverage
      Shareholder Information
      • Acquisitions
      • Dividends
      • Drip
      • FAQ
      Featured Content
      Thn-Web-Q42020-Results

      WSP's Q4 and 2020 Results

      We released our 2020 fourth quarter and fiscal results on February 24, 2021 after market close.

    • Investors
      • Corporate Governance
        • Investors
        • Corporate Governance
          • Audit Committee
          • Board of Directors
          • Business Conduct Hotline
          • Constating Documents
          • Governance Documents
          • Governance Ethics and Compensation Committee
          • Mandates
      • Press Releases
      • Reports & Filings
        • Investors
        • REPORTS & FILINGS
          • AIF
          • Annual
          • Information Circular
          • Quarterly
          • SEDAR Filings
          • Sustainability
      • Stock Information
        • Investors
        • Stock Information
          • Analyst Coverage
      • Shareholder Information
        • Investors
        • Shareholder Information
          • Acquisitions
          • Dividends
          • Drip
          • FAQ
      • Presentations and Events
    • News
      • Latest News
      • Press Releases
    • Contact us
      • Send a Message
      • Offices
  1. home
  2. Insights
  3. Plato For Plumbers Philosophy And Engineering

Plato For Plumbers: Philosophy And Engineering

In his award-winning essay for New Philosopher magazine, WSP’s Mark Bessoudo explains why engineers should read more philosophy

25 April 2018
Reading Time : 6 minutes

Engineers Are Not Given The Proper Intellectual Tools

It’s a truism to remark how much our world is becoming increasingly technological, exponentially complex.
The pace of change is evident in our everyday experience. From the grand feats of transcontinental flight to the mundane tasks of flushing the toilet to the seemingly miraculous joy of accessing the world’s knowledge through the smartphone in your pocket, we are at once passive and active participants in a landscape that has become progressively mechanized, digitized, and automated.

Behind the scenes, this technical infrastructure is being planned, designed, constructed and maintained largely by one type of person: the engineer. Whether we realize it or not, it is the humble engineer who now forms the clay which moulds not only our external environment, but also our mind’s interior realm. As we enter the geological era known as the Anthropocene, the engineer has also become, perhaps unwittingly, an ecological force on a planetary scale.

There’s just one problem: at almost no point in their education, training, or practice are engineers given the proper intellectual tools with which to reflect, in any meaningful way, on themselves, each other, or their world-transforming enterprise. Engineers, and the general public, rarely stop to ask: “Should we do this, simply because we can? Is this actually good for the betterment of humanity or for the planet?”

Questions about value, virtue, beauty and justice cannot be factored into any of the engineer’s equations and so are easily dismissed. Yet, for anyone with eyes to see, the connections between engineering and the good life are obvious.

The Iron Ring For Engineers

Like other engineering students in Canada who are close to graduating from university, I participated in a ceremony called The Ritual of the Calling of the Engineer, a peculiar and somewhat secretive tradition (developed by the British writer Rudyard Kipling, no less) which culminates with each student receiving an iron ring.

Legend has it that each ring is made from the iron of a bridge that collapsed (twice) into Quebec’s St. Lawrence River in the early 20th century. The disasters were blamed on a combination of negligence, structural deficiencies and faulty calculations. In all, almost 90 people were killed.

The ring is therefore meant to be worn as a reminder of our professional commitment to public safety and to maintaining the highest standards of ethics. It’s worn on the little finger of the dominant hand so that each time the engineer puts pen to paper it creates a noticeable, if dulled, clang! The frequent reminders are meant to be both tactile and intellectual, like the Stoics’ unification of the technē (the practice of an art or craft) with the epistēmē (the theory of knowledge).

Questioning The Social, Moral And Environmental Impact

Engineers may indeed be standing on the shoulders of giants, but we’re never encouraged to spend too much time looking down at those we stand on, or stopping to consider our place. We’re encouraged to look up, innovate and never look back.

Innovation is something that the practice of engineering particularly prides itself on, but few in the profession ever question the pursuit itself; still fewer question our culture’s techno-optimistic assumptions about progress. Instead, institutions and corporations resort to trite cliches about the many blessings that the pursuit of technological innovation bestows upon us: greater efficiency, material progress, economic growth, and so on. The act of innovating becomes the end goal, rather than a means to some other, nobler end.

In The Republic, Plato proposed that the ideal city-state could not be realized without being ruled by wisdom-loving philosopher kings. “Until philosophers rule as kings or those who are now called kings and leading men genuinely and adequately philosophize,” Plato warned, “… there can be no happiness, either public or private, in any other city.”

Devoid of the cognitive toolkit necessary to enquire about the social, moral and environmental impact of their work, engineers have the capacity to create artefacts and systems that can negatively impinge upon those around them, often with unintended consequences, like a kind of technological secondhand smoke.

Integrating Philosophy In The Engineer’s Training

What’s urgently needed, then, is obviously not for philosophy to replace technical training, but rather for philosophy to complement it. The relevance of philosophy to engineering must be made more visible to encourage the creation of a more humanistic approach to engineering. What’s needed, in other words, are wisdom-loving philosopher-engineers.

An understanding of human values and moral decision-making will soon mean big business in the tech industry. Many of the classical thought experiments once confined to the classrooms of Philosophy 101 may soon become part of everyday reality for the tech workers in the open-plan offices and labs of Silicon Valley. Moral philosophy may even become a key industry sector.

Take, for example, self-driving cars and the issue of safety with automatic collision detection. It is engineers who have been handed the task of having to solve multiple real-world versions of the “trolley problem” and code it into software. Or virtual reality. Although in its infancy, it is already changing many of our assumptions about personal identity and what constitutes the self. According to philosopher and cognitive scientist David Chalmers, VR is reframing some of philosophy’s most enduring questions about epistemology and the nature of reality.

Wellbeing And Engineering

Then there’s the tricky possibility (inevitability?) of one day inventing an artificial general intelligence (AGI) — a machine or system that can perform intellectual tasks better than any human can. This would require solving some very old problems in moral philosophy. Once again, it is engineers who are being relied on to program concepts such as goodness, benevolence and morality into the AGI. And if you believe, as some experts do, that the invention of an AGI poses a unique existential risk, then even our solar system’s very existence may well depend on engineers converging on the correct answer; furthermore, we may only be afforded one chance to accomplish it.

“I wish it would dawn on engineers,” wrote the Spanish philosopher José Ortega y Gasset, “that, in order to be an engineer, it is not enough to be an engineer.” I, too, hope that my fellow engineers will take it upon themselves to start thinking clearly about what it means to be human. To the questions like “Is it more efficient?” and “How much does it cost?”, we must also ask: “Is it good? Does it contribute to wellbeing? For whom? By what standard?”

To critically reflect on the meaning of life and the future of civilization in this way is perhaps a new form of humanism. And, as is appropriate to our progressively engineered world, it is an approach in which engineers could — no, must — lead the way.

Pen and paper are rarely used by engineers today, so the iron ring no longer serves the same purpose that it once did. There’s no noticeable clang! when one works on a desktop, tablet or smartphone. Gone are the frequent reminders of our obligation to ethics.

Who knows — maybe in the end, despite all our best efforts, technology itself will find a way to obstruct any attempt of ours to instil more humanism into engineering.

Mark Bessoudo is research manager and sustainability consultant at WSP in Toronto. He is also founder of platoforplumbers.com. This essay was originally published in New Philosopher magazine, as the winner of the Writers’ Award XI on the theme of technology.

 

Article originally published on www.the-possible.com 


More on this subject

thn-insights-designing-built-environment

February 2021

Designing the Built Environment Through a Wider Lens

Australia
Society , Climate , COVID-19 , Resilience
Indigenous Cultures-Thumbnail

February 2021

Embracing Indigenous Cultures to Address Infrastructure Needs

Feature
Places , Resilience , Society
GB-ChantelleMartin-27012021-563x220

January 2021

An hour in the life of a Business Support Partner

United Kingdom
Feature
Society
thn-what-else-Net-zero-better-normal

January 2021 | 11 minutes

What Else Can Net Zero Do For Us?

Blog
Resilience , Resources , Society , COVID-19
Manchester urban planning 1563 x 220

January 2021 | 10 minutes

Planning for Recovery: In conversation with Sean Anstee CBE

United Kingdom
Feature
Resilience , Society , Places
Change Makers Rebranded-51

January 2021

An hour in the life of an occupational health and safety advisor

United Kingdom
Blog
Resilience , Society
the-key-to-creating-social-value-is-leaving-a-tangible-outcome-focused-legacy-thn

January 2021

The key to creating social value is leaving a tangible, outcome-focused legacy

United Kingdom
Feature
Places , Climate , Society
thn-wsp-uber-whitepaper

December 2020

Future Ready Kerbside: Creating Places That Put People First

Australia
White Paper
Places , Resilience , Society
Thn-Web-VZ-ITS-Article5

November 2020

Designing Out Flaws Within Road Transportation Systems

Feature
Mobility , Places , Resilience , Society , Technology
thn-news-waterways

November 2020 | 2 minutes

Water at the heart of long-term thinking for sustainable urban development

New Zealand
Feature
Places , Climate , Society
suzanna thn

November 2020

Suzanna Massingue - Future Mobility Consultant

United Kingdom
Feature
Mobility , Society
Cities after COVID

November 2020 | 15 minutes

Cities After COVID: How Can We Create A Positive Legacy For Health And Wellbeing?

Feature
COVID-19 , Places , Resilience , Society

Share this page

  • Share on Facebook - Warning, this link will open a new tab.
  • Share on Linkedin - Warning, this link will open a new tab.
  • Share on Twitter - Warning, this link will open a new tab.
  • Share on Skype - Warning, this link will open your Skype application.


Related themes and tags

  • Society (165)


  •  
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  • Who We Are
  • What We Stand For
  • Our Story
  • Future Ready
  • UK Leadership
  • Our Offices
  • What We Do
  • Sectors
  • Services
  • Projects
  • Insights
  • Climate
  • Mobility
  • Places
  • Society
  • Resources
  • Technology
  • Careers
  • Job Opportunities
  • Spontaneous Application
  • Corporate
  • Sustainability
  • Health and Safety
  • Investors
  • Business Conduct Hotline
  • News
  • Corporate Governance
  • Ethics and Integrity
    ©2021 WSP
    • The WSP Logo
    • Privacy Notice
    • Anti-Spam Commitment
    • WSP Slavery Prevention Policy
    • UK Corporate Governance Statement
    • UK Gender Pay Report
    • UK Modern Slavery Statement
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Use
    ©2021 WSP

    Exiting our Website

    You are about to leave WSP.com and are being redirected to a job opportunity at Louis Berger, which has been recently acquired by WSP in the US.