Quantifying a Common Safety Target for Tunnels | WSP Skip to content
  • Who We Are

    We are the sum of our collective passion, vision and expertise.

    Discover our people, purpose and stories that have helped shape the organization we are today and are inspiring the one we will become.

    Who We Are
    • What We Stand For
    • Our Story
    • Corporate Responsibility
    • U.S. Leadership
    Corporate Responsibility
    • Communities
    • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity and Inclusion
    • Ethics and Integrity
    • Health and Safety
    • Sustainability
    Featured Content
    We value - Square

    Can we help societies thrive in a world we do not…

    We believe that for societies to thrive, we must all hold ourselves accountable for tomorrow. That…

  • What We Do

    We shape the communities of tomorrow and help society thrive.

    With an intimate sense of local realities, we look at complex problems from different angles and deliver solutions that break paradigms.


    View All

    • Sectors
    • Services
    • Projects
    What We Do
    • Property and Buildings
    • Transportation
    • Water and Environment
    • Energy
    • Federal Programs & Logistics
    • Advisory Services
    Property and Buildings
    • Building Enclosures
    • Building Technology Systems
    • Built Ecology
    • Commercial
    • Commissioning
    • Healthcare
    • High-Rise
    • Hospitality
    • Lighting Design
    • MEP Engineering
    • Residential
    • Science & Technology
    • Structural Engineering
    Transportation
    • Alternative Delivery
    • Aviation
    • Highways and Bridges
    • Maritime
    • Mobility Operations
    • Program and Construction Management
    • Transit and Rail
    • Tunnels
    Water and Environment
    • Acoustics, Vibration, Green House Gases and Air Quality
    • Archaelogy and Heritage Buildings
    • Asbestos and Hazardous Materials Management
    • Contaminated Land and Soil Remediation
    • Environment
    • Environmental Due Diligence
    • Flood Control and Hydraulic Structures
    • Hydraulic and Hydrologic Analysis
    • Hydrogeology
    • Industrial and Manufacturing
    • Mine Water Management
    • Natural Environment and Ecology
    • Oil and Gas
    • Sustainability, Energy and Climate Change
    • Water
    • Water and Wastewater Treatment and Conveyance
    • Water Conveyance Tunnels
    • Water Supply and Reuse
    Energy
    • Energy Services and Central Utility Plants
    • Energy Storage Facility Operations
    • Energy Surface Facilities
    • Hydropower and Dams
    • Power Generation and Delivery
    • Solar Energy
    • Storage and Disposal Wells
    • Underground Injection Control and Permitting
    • Underground Storage and Disposal
    • Wind Energy
    Federal Programs & Logistics
    • Environment
    • Environmental Planning
    • Government
    • Logistics and Emergency Management
    • Operations and Maintenance
    • Overseas Integrated Development
    • Safety and Security Program
    • Science and Technology
    • Strategic Environmental Assessment
    • Urban and Community Planning
    Advisory Services
    • Alternative Delivery
    • Asset Management
    • Business Improvement
    • Economic and Market Analysis
    • Environmental Planning
    • Freight and Logistics
    • Planning Strategy and Grants
    • Policy and Research
    • Project Development and Finance
    • Technology and Innovation
    • Transportation Planning
    • Urban and Community Planning
    Featured Content
    bnr-water-campaign2020a

    Surface Water: Into the Hydrosphere

    Water is perhaps our most essential resource — at once shaping and sustaining both the natural…

  • Insights

    Our global experts offer compelling insights that provide new perspectives.

    Read inspiring articles that challenge the status quo by reframing current issues, sparking fresh conversations and finding new solutions.

    View all
    Insights
    • Climate
    • Mobility
    • Places
    • Resources
    • Society
    • Technology
    Featured Content
    bnr-covid-19-meritus-health-aerial

    Meritus Medical Creating Infectious Containment…

    Leach Wallace, a WSP Company, is part of a team acting swiftly to design and build one of the first…

  • Careers

    Help us shape the future

    Join a collaborative team of experts that thrives on complex challenges and unconventional thinking.

    See more
    Careers
    • Join Us
    • Early Career
    • Experienced Professionals
    • Why Choose WSP
    Featured Content
    bnr-wsp-WSP-Ranked-7-ENR-500

    WSP USA Jumps to #7 in ENR’s 2020 Ranking of the…

    The firm ranked second for the "Top 100 Pure Designers."

  • Who We Are
    • What We Stand For
    • Our Story
    • Corporate Responsibility
      • Who We Are
      • Accountable for Tomorrow
        • Communities
        • Corporate Governance
        • Diversity and Inclusion
        • Ethics and Integrity
        • Health and Safety
        • Sustainability
    • U.S. Leadership
  • What We Do
    • Property and Buildings
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Building Enclosures
        • Building Technology Systems
        • Built Ecology
        • Commercial
        • Commissioning
        • Healthcare
        • High-Rise
        • Hospitality
        • Lighting Design
        • MEP Engineering
        • Residential
        • Science & Technology
        • Structural Engineering
    • Transportation
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Alternative Delivery
        • Aviation
        • Highways and Bridges
        • Maritime
        • Mobility Operations
        • Program and Construction Management
        • Transit and Rail
        • Tunnels
    • Water and Environment
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Acoustics, Vibration, Green House Gases and Air Quality
        • Archaelogy and Heritage Buildings
        • Asbestos and Hazardous Materials Management
        • Contaminated Land and Soil Remediation
        • Environment
        • Environmental Due Diligence
        • Flood Control and Hydraulic Structures
        • Hydraulic and Hydrologic Analysis
        • Hydrogeology
        • Industrial and Manufacturing
        • Mine Water Management
        • Natural Environment and Ecology
        • Oil and Gas
        • Sustainability, Energy and Climate Change
        • Water
        • Water and Wastewater Treatment and Conveyance
        • Water Conveyance Tunnels
        • Water Risk Management
        • Water Supply and Reuse
    • Energy
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Energy Services and Central Utility Plants
        • Energy Storage Facility Operations
        • Energy Surface Facilities
        • Hydropower and Dams
        • Power Generation and Delivery
        • Solar Energy
        • Storage and Disposal Wells
        • Underground Injection Control and Permitting
        • Underground Storage and Disposal
        • Wind Energy
    • Federal Programs & Logistics
      • What We Do
        • Environment
        • Environmental Planning
        • Government
        • Logistics and Emergency Management
        • Operations and Maintenance
        • Overseas Integrated Development
        • Safety and Security Program
        • Science and Technology
        • Strategic Environmental Assessment
        • Urban and Community Planning
    • Advisory Services
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Alternative Delivery
        • Asset Management
        • Business Improvement
        • Economic and Market Analysis
        • Environmental Planning
        • Freight and Logistics
        • Planning Strategy and Grants
        • Policy and Research
        • Project Development and Finance
        • Technology and Innovation
        • Transportation Planning
        • Urban and Community Planning
  • Insights
    • Climate
    • Mobility
    • Places
    • Resources
    • Society
    • Technology
  • Careers
    • Join Us
    • Early Career
    • Experienced Professionals
    • Why Choose WSP
Back

We are locally dedicated with international scale.

United States - English

International

  • Global
    English - Français

Americas

  • Canada
    English - Français
  • Chile
    Español
  • Colombia
    Español
  • Mexico
    Español
  • Panama
    Español
  • Peru
    Español
  • United States
    English

Africa

  • South Africa
    English

Asia

  • China
    中文(简体) - English
  • Hong Kong
    English
  • India
    English
  • Malaysia
    English
  • Philippines
    English
  • Singapore
    English
  • South Korea
    한국어(대한민국) - English
  • Thailand
    English

Europe

  • Denmark
    Dansk
  • Finland
    Suomi
  • France
    Français
  • Germany
    Deutsch
  • Greenland
    Kalaallisut - English
  • Netherlands
    Nederlands
  • Norway
    Norsk
  • Poland
    Polski - English
  • Romania
    English
  • Spain
    Español
  • Sweden
    Svenska - English
  • Switzerland
    Deutsch - English
  • United Kingdom
    English

Middle East

  • Kuwait
    English
  • Oman
    English
  • Qatar
    English
  • Saudi Arabia
    English
  • United Arab Emirates
    English

Oceania

  • Australia
    English
  • New Zealand
    English
Worldwide Offices
    • Investors

      Discover our diverse business, financial results and strategic ambitions.

      We are committed to delivering sustainable value to our shareholders and exceptional professional services to our clients.

      Read more
      Investors
      • Corporate Governance
      • Press Releases
      • Reports & Filings
      • Stock Information
      • Shareholder Information
      • Presentations and Events
      Corporate Governance
      • Audit Committee
      • Board of Directors
      • Business Conduct Hotline
      • Constating Documents
      • Governance Documents
      • Governance Ethics and Compensation Committee
      • Mandates
      Reports & Filings
      • AIF
      • Annual
      • Information Circular
      • Quarterly
      • SEDAR Filings
      • Sustainability
      Stock Information
      • Analyst Coverage
      Shareholder Information
      • Acquisitions
      • Dividends
      • Drip
      • FAQ
      Featured Content

      WSP's Q3 2020 Results

      We released our 2020 third quarter results on November 4, 2020 after market close

    • Investors
      • Corporate Governance
        • Investors
        • Corporate Governance
          • Audit Committee
          • Board of Directors
          • Business Conduct Hotline
          • Constating Documents
          • Governance Documents
          • Governance Ethics and Compensation Committee
          • Mandates
      • Press Releases
      • Reports & Filings
        • Investors
        • REPORTS & FILINGS
          • AIF
          • Annual
          • Information Circular
          • Quarterly
          • SEDAR Filings
          • Sustainability
      • Stock Information
        • Investors
        • Stock Information
          • Analyst Coverage
      • Shareholder Information
        • Investors
        • Shareholder Information
          • Acquisitions
          • Dividends
          • Drip
          • FAQ
      • Presentations and Events
    • Events
    • News
    • Contact us

      We are dedicated to our local communities and driven by global talent.

      Contact us to find out how our diversified offering, world-class expertise and geographical reach can assist you in achieving your vision.


      Follow us

      Contact us
      • Send a Message
      • Offices
      Featured Content
      bnr-future-ready-global

      Future Ready

      We know that our future world will be very different from today’s in many ways. Future Ready is our…

    • Investors

      Discover our diverse business, financial results and strategic ambitions.

      We are committed to delivering sustainable value to our shareholders and exceptional professional services to our clients.

      Read more
      Investors
      • Corporate Governance
      • Press Releases
      • Reports & Filings
      • Stock Information
      • Shareholder Information
      • Presentations and Events
      Corporate Governance
      • Audit Committee
      • Board of Directors
      • Business Conduct Hotline
      • Constating Documents
      • Governance Documents
      • Governance Ethics and Compensation Committee
      • Mandates
      Reports & Filings
      • AIF
      • Annual
      • Information Circular
      • Quarterly
      • SEDAR Filings
      • Sustainability
      Stock Information
      • Analyst Coverage
      Shareholder Information
      • Acquisitions
      • Dividends
      • Drip
      • FAQ
      Featured Content

      WSP's Q3 2020 Results

      We released our 2020 third quarter results on November 4, 2020 after market close

    • Investors
      • Corporate Governance
        • Investors
        • Corporate Governance
          • Audit Committee
          • Board of Directors
          • Business Conduct Hotline
          • Constating Documents
          • Governance Documents
          • Governance Ethics and Compensation Committee
          • Mandates
      • Press Releases
      • Reports & Filings
        • Investors
        • REPORTS & FILINGS
          • AIF
          • Annual
          • Information Circular
          • Quarterly
          • SEDAR Filings
          • Sustainability
      • Stock Information
        • Investors
        • Stock Information
          • Analyst Coverage
      • Shareholder Information
        • Investors
        • Shareholder Information
          • Acquisitions
          • Dividends
          • Drip
          • FAQ
      • Presentations and Events
    • Events
    • News
    • Contact us
      • Send a Message
      • Offices
  1. We are WSP
  2. Insights
  3. Quantifying a Common Safety Target for Tunnels

Quantifying a Common Safety Target for Tunnels

A safety target for road tunnels, railway tunnels and subway systems is essential during the planning and approval stages of tunnel projects. The required level of safety in such tunnels is generally considered unclear and discussions regarding it difficult. Our experts provide an overview of a research project commissioned by the Swedish Transport Agency (STA) focused on how to facilitate the quantification of a common target for traffic tunnels, and produce a clear outcome.

map marker Sweden | Thursday, June 7, 2018
Reading Time : 20 minutes

This article was written in collaboration with WSP Director of Technical Risk Johan Lundin. It was first presented as a part of the 8th edition of the International Symposium on Tunnel Safety and Security (ISTSS) in Borås, Sweden.

Abstract

This paper focuses on quantifying a common safety target level that can be used to verify safety levels in road tunnels, railway tunnels, and subway systems with regards to life safety. This safety target should provide a risk acceptance level, according to which tunnel projects can be compared to one another while factoring in the benefit of the tunnel in terms of the value of transporting people and goods. In order to ascertain a reasonable safety target, risk acceptance levels of regulations and recent tunnel projects were studied. The estimated risk levels of recent road and railway tunnel projects were also identified, and converted into the same entity of risk. These risk levels were also compared to estimated risk levels of several fictional road and railway tunnels that comply with current standards, with and without the transportation of dangerous goods.

There are large differences in how risk is expressed in road and railway tunnel projects, and none of the projects or regulations studied fully factor in the societal benefit of traffic when formulating safety target as a societal risk profile. Risk-benefit assessment, however, is quite common in the projects studied. The railway tunnel risk acceptance levels used by the Swedish Transport Administration (Trafikverket) are close to incorporate these benefits, as they state risk on the basis of train-km, whereas other bodies and projects only consider the tunnel as a whole or state it in terms of tunnel-km. The analysis of calculated risk levels shows that they can be stated on the basis of risk per person-km, which provides comparable data for the different transport systems and are directly proportional to transport benefits. Risk acceptance criteria for all three transport systems can preferably be measured in deaths per person-km for societal risk profiles. This unit does not state the total risk of each facility; rather, it allows an ALARP zone to be created, which allows a risk-benefit comparison to be performed. In this paper, it is suggested that risk acceptance levels should be set just above those of tunnel projects that have recently been approved by the Swedish Transport Agency (Transportstyrelsen), and that the establishing of ALARP zones should be a requirement in these processes, as this promotes risk assessment and the design of cost-effective tunnel systems.

Download the Full Text Here

Related Publications

thn-mlk-street-closure-encourages-recreation

December 2020 | 3:00 minutes

WSP USA Study: Street Closure Encourages Recreational Activity During Pandemic

United States
White Paper
COVID-19 , Mobility
bnr-tdot-i440-reconstruction

December 2020 | 4:15 minutes

Tennessee DOT Completes State’s Largest Highway Project

United States
Feature
Mobility
thn-san-antonio-future-ready-howard-peak-greenway-trail

November 2020 | 6:30 minutes

A Perspective on a Future Ready City: San Antonio

United States
Feature
Mobility , Resilience
thn-ohare-airport-taxiway-z-paving-complete

October 2020 | 4:30 minutes

Taxiway Project Improves Winter Air Travel Efficiency at O’Hare

United States
Feature
Mobility
bnr-bart-extension-train-boarding

October 2020 | 5:15 minutes

Bay Area Rapid Transit Rail Expansion Opens Line to San Jose

United States
Feature
Mobility
thn-transit-in-new-normal-covid-art

October 2020 | 6:45 minutes

Planning for Transit in the New Normal Post-Covid-19

United States
Feature
Mobility , COVID-19
thn-Web-Asset-Mgmt-Resilience

October 2020

Asset Management Prepares Organizations for Unexpected Events

Feature
Resilience , Places , Society , Mobility , COVID-19 , Resources
thn-caltrans-climate-change-bixby-creek-bridge

September 2020 | 5:30 minutes

Assessing Climate Change Vulnerabilities on California Highways

United States
Feature
Climate , Mobility
thn-insights-sustainable-transportation

September 2020

Cultivating Sustainable Transport Systems

Feature
COVID-19 , Mobility , Places , Resilience
thn-nj-transit-wlf-hoboken

August 2020 | 6:00 minutes

NJ TRANSIT Adopts Plan for Statewide Public Transportation Improvements

United States
Feature
Mobility
thn-future-ready-car-park

August 2020

The Future Ready Commuter Car Park

Australia
Feature
Mobility , COVID-19 , Society
thn-california high speed train

July 2020

Achieving Systems Integration through Interoperability

Technical Paper
Mobility , Resources

Author

Erik Hällstorp
Sweden

Share this page

  • Share on Facebook - link will open a new tab.
  • Share on Linkedin - link will open a new tab
  • Share on Twitter - this link will open a new tab
  • Share on Skype - Warning, this link will open your Skype application.


Related themes and tags

  • Mobility (145)


  • Compliance (5)
  • Fire and Safety (2)
  • Infrastructure (50)
  • Innovation (21)
  • Transportation (111)
  • Transit (41)
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  • Who We Are
  • What We Stand For
  • Our Story
  • Future Ready
  • U.S. Leadership
  • Our Offices
  • What We Do
  • Sectors
  • Services
  • Projects
  • Insights
  • Climate
  • Mobility
  • Places
  • Society
  • Resources
  • Technology
  • Careers
  • U.S. Job Opportunities
  • Apply Here
  • Supplier Registration Page will open in a new tab
  • FEMA Inspection Services Page will open in a new tab
  • Corporate
  • Sustainability
  • Health and Safety
  • Investors
  • Whistleblowing Service
  • News
  • Corporate Governance
  • Ethics and Integrity
    ©2021 WSP
    • The WSP Logo
    • Privacy Policy
    • Anti-Spam Commitment
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Use
    ©2021 WSP

    Exiting our Website

    You are about to leave WSP.com and are being redirected to a job opportunity at Louis Berger, which has been recently acquired by WSP in the US.