What is the Risk of Not Investing in Nature?
Experts from around the world have been stressing to financial institutions that greater spending is needed for global nature protection and restoration efforts, but few have explained why it should be this sector, as opposed to government, to take on some of the investment burden. The Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, established in December 2022 in Montreal, called for “… legal, administrative or policy measures to encourage and enable business, and in particular to ensure that large and transnational companies and financial institutions.”
The stakes are high for the finance sector. The risk of not investing in nature is significant. The impact of failing to act is substantial. But the potential for positive progress is enormous.
It’s imperative that financial institutions understand the risks related to biodiversity loss, and take swift action to both protect their investments and find ways to spend on nature-based initiatives. As noted in the recent World Economic Forum’s Global Risks Report 2024, “…the triggering of a nexus of several related socioenvironmental risks has the potential to speed up climate change, through the release of carbon emissions, and amplify related impacts, threatening climate-vulnerable populations.”
Engaging the Sector
For both economic and social reasons, it’s important for the finance sector to understand how nature impacts their portfolio.
From an economic perspective, assets in which financial institutions invest have dependencies to nature and impacts on nature. Climate change has exposed vulnerabilities in some of those assets, which can lead to potentially significant costs related to regulatory breaches, operational disruptions, legal actions, and liability risks. Those risks need to be understood and managed.
From a social perspective, institutions rely on strong stakeholder engagement from investors. With preferences shifting increasingly to social and sustainable consciousness, this is pressuring financial institutions to prioritize nature to maintain their reputation and market positioning.
Financial Institutions thus need to clearly understand and manage their implication with nature, at the portfolio level as well as at asset level, to maintain their attractiveness to investors.
Understanding the Risks
There are risks related to nature impacts and dependencies at the asset level, and there are indirect risks for the finance sector itself, linked to asset impacts and dependencies. This leads to reputational and regulatory issues, thus creating financial consequences.
It’s important to understand the specific nature-based risks associated with investments to be able to act on them:
Regulatory Risk
Inaction on biodiversity damages may lead to litigations and legal liabilities due to environmental harm, like what has been seen in the mining, oil and gas, and development sectors.
Reputation Risk
As mentioned above, damage to nature or inaction by companies within an investment portfolio can cause significant reputational harm to a financial institution, such as what’s happened with calls for banks to divest from investing in high-emissions energy technologies.
Financial Risk
Failing to address nature and nature loss has significant costs; no action could impact reputation and attractiveness, leading to a major decrease of investments. Also, operational disruptions at the asset level due to inaction on biodiversity could indirectly have an impact on the financial institution, in addition to the regulatory risk mentioned above that could also lead to claims / lawsuits or financial penalties for negligence or failure to mitigate risks.
Environmental Risk
Without adaptation, climate change will harm the environment, affecting ecosystems, water resources, and nature. This can disrupt economic activities and investments at the global scale.
Understanding each risk, and where it exists within the institution’s investment portfolio, provides greater appreciation of the actions that need to be taken.
Creating a Return on the Investment
Financial accountability is important in addressing nature. Those working to protect and restore nature recognize that there needs to be a legitimate appreciation for how the investment will provide returns.
By controlling and managing nature-related risks at the portfolio level, financial institutions can minimize financial, regulatory, reputational risks related to nature in their investments. This can increase an investor’s willingness to put money into the portfolio. Also, by integrating nature-based considerations into investment decisions, financial institutions can ensure sustainable investments that protect biodiversity. This can improve investor confidence, leading to long-term profitability and portfolio resilience.
Stakeholder engagement, mostly with investors, clients and communities, is a key lever for financial institutions. Demonstrating transparency about nature, showing ongoing initiatives and their positive impact, fosters trust for all stakeholders and attracts socially-conscious investors.
Financial institutions can also utilize biodiversity valuation metrics to quantify the value of ecosystem services in their investment portfolio, including but not limited to: pollination, water purification, and carbon sequestration. Each of these can contribute to the overall return on investment.
Communicating with Investors
The ROI discussion has to be communicated with investors, as the benefits of spending on nature has to be clearly understood to obtain the necessary buy-in.
It’s important to show how nature-based impacts long-term financial stability, using a clear biodiversity impact assessment at the portfolio level, that focuses on related risks mentioned previously. It is important to integrate nature considerations into an investor’s overall strategy, showing that these implications have been well understood and prioritized, and also showing real commitments to nature-based initiatives, conservation efforts and risk management.
Communicating the success of the investments is just as important. Regularly reporting on those biodiversity initiatives, performance, and related impacts, using clear and transparent communication about conservation efforts, risk management, and positive outcomes, builds trust and helps engage both clients and shareholders. Also, by educating stakeholders about nature’s role in economic resilience and ecosystem services through the use of workshops, webinars, and educational materials, can foster understanding and encourage support for biodiversity-focused investment.
By creating tools to facilitate an open dialogue on nature-based investments, financial institutions are better positioned to convince investors of the value of the expense.
Beginning the Journey
The journey takes time, but there are some tools available to help take the first steps. Some existing frameworks like TNFD (Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures), SBTN (Science Based Targets Network) and ACT-D can support financial institutions to start their journey towards the development of a Biodiversity Strategy.
Beyond that, there are two fundamental areas to focus on:
Assess the Impacts: Start by evaluating the impact of existing investments and operations on nature. Understand the impacts, dependencies on natural resources and identify potential risks and opportunities.
Integrate Nature into Strategy and Policy: Develop policies that explicitly address biodiversity. Consider nature-based initiatives, measurement metrics, investment criteria, and risk management strategies.
We are still in the early stages of an era in which nature will be at the heart of our economic and financial system: for that, itis important to keep learning and collaborating. Doing so will lead your institution to a successful, and profitable, approach to the natural environment.
Author: Julie Pizzutto is a Senior Advisor for ESG and Climate Change Strategic Advisory at WSP in Canada.
WSP can help you on your journey, connect with our biodiversity specialists today: