Skip to content
WSP WSP
WSP WSP
  • Who we are
    We are the home of ambitious, passionate, and innovative engineering experts, scientists and advisors.

    Read more
    Who we are
    • Our story
    • Future Ready
    • Corporate responsibility
    • Our Offices
    • UK and Ireland Leadership
    • Global Strategic Plan
    • Our impact
    Corporate responsibility
    • Communities
    • Corporate governance
    • Ethics and integrity
    • Health and safety
    • Inclusion and belonging
    • Sustainability
    • UK Policies
    Featured content
    thn-strat-plan-2025
    Pioneering change for empowered growth

    As world shapers, our 2025-2027 Global Strategic Action Plan captures our…

  • What We Do
    We shape the communities of tomorrow and help society thrive.

    Our understanding of local, regional and national needs enables us to deliver solutions that better connect people with places, now and in the future.


    View All

    • Sectors
    • Services
    • Projects
    What We Do
    • Property and buildings
    • Transport and infrastructure
    • Earth and environment
    • Digital services and solutions
    • Planning and development
    • Energy
    • Water
    • Advisory
    Property and buildings
    • Commercial and mixed use
    • Cultural
    • Decarbonising property & buildings
    • Education
    • Existing Buildings
    • Healthcare
    • Heritage
    • High-rise
    • How to net zero
    • Industry
    • Local government
    • Mission critical facilities
    • Modern methods of construction
    • Pharmaceuticals and life science
    • Placemaking development and urban regeneration
    • Residential
    • Sports and stadia
    • Town planning and consulting
    • Workplace
    Transport and infrastructure
    • Asset management
    • Aviation
    • Bridges
    • Defence
    • How to net zero
    • Infrastructure planning and consulting
    • Local government
    • Maritime
    • Project, programme and commercial management
    • Rail and transit
    • Roads and highways
    • Transport planning
    • Tunnels
    Earth and environment
    • Acoustics, noise and vibration
    • Air quality
    • Asbestos and hazardous material
    • Cultural heritage and archaeology
    • Environmental assessment and management
    • How to net zero
    • Kit-of-parts approach
    • Landscape Architecture
    • Nature-based solutions
    • Waste management
    • Water
    Digital services and solutions
    • Daisy
    • Data science advisory solutions
    • Digital and data advisory services
    • Digital solutions for water
    • Digital transport planning
    • How to net zero
    • Kit of parts
    Planning and development
    • Environmental assessment and management
    • How to net zero
    • Infrastructure planning and consulting
    • Land referencing and land assembly
    • Landscape architecture
    • Local government
    • Placemaking development and urban regeneration
    • Stakeholder engagement and strategic communications
    • Town planning and consulting
    • Transport planning
    • Urban planning and design
    Energy
    • Energy transition
    • How to net zero
    • Hydrogen energy
    • Nuclear energy
    • Offshore wind
    • Solar energy
    Water
    • Asset management for water
    • Desalination
    • Digital solutions for water
    • Drinking water supply
    • How to net zero
    • Industrial water
    • Minewater management
    • Nature based solutions
    • Storm water and flood risk management
    • Wastewater treatment
    • Water infrastructure
    • Water planning and advisory
    • Water resources
    Advisory
    • Asset management
    • Data Science Advisory Solutions
    • Digital advisory
    • Economics
    • ESG strategy
    • How to net zero
    • Investor and lenders advisory
    • Net zero and sustainability advisory
    • Project, programme and commercial management
    • Public private partnerships and capital investment
    • Transformation and change management
    Featured content
    thn-net-zero
    How to Net Zero

    How WSP can help you decarbonise with confidence

  • Insights
    Our experts offer compelling insights that provide new perspectives.

    Read inspiring articles that challenge the status quo by reframing current issues, sparking fresh ideas and conversations.

    View all
    Insights
    • Climate
    • Mobility
    • Places
    • Resources
    • Society
    • Technology
    Featured content
    thumbnail-water-research
    Navigating the Waters of Change

    We explore the urgent global water crisis, the innovative strategies being employed…

  • Careers
    What if you could do the kind of work the world needs?

    With us, you can. Make your best impact with WSP, where the culture and people also make it the best work of your life.

    Find out more
    Careers
    • Job opportunities
    • Early Career
    • Experienced Professionals
    • Why join us?
    Featured content
    Thn-Web-Careers-Landing
    Careers in Engineering, Professional Services & the…

    Shape a better future for us all and a brighter future for you. With us, you can.

  • Who we are
    • Our story
    • Future Ready
    • Corporate responsibility
      • Who we are
      • Accountable for Tomorrow
        • Communities
        • Corporate governance
        • Ethics and integrity
        • Health and safety
        • Inclusion and belonging
        • Sustainability
        • UK Policies
    • Our Offices
    • UK and Ireland Leadership
    • Global Strategic Plan
    • Our impact
  • What We Do
    • Property and buildings
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Commercial and mixed use
        • Cultural
        • Decarbonising property & buildings
        • Education
        • Existing Buildings
        • Healthcare
        • Heritage
        • High-rise
        • How to net zero
        • Industry
        • Local government
        • Mission critical facilities
        • Modern methods of construction
        • Pharmaceuticals and life science
        • Placemaking development and urban regeneration
        • Residential
        • Sports and stadia
        • Town planning and consulting
        • Workplace
    • Transport and infrastructure
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Asset management
        • Aviation
        • Bridges
        • Defence
        • How to net zero
        • Infrastructure planning and consulting
        • Local government
        • Maritime
        • Project, programme and commercial management
        • Rail and transit
        • Roads and highways
        • Transport planning
        • Tunnels
    • Earth and environment
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Acoustics, noise and vibration
        • Air quality
        • Asbestos and hazardous material
        • Climate Resilience
        • Cultural heritage and archaeology
        • Environmental assessment and management
        • How to net zero
        • Kit-of-parts approach
        • Landscape Architecture
        • Nature-based solutions
        • Net Zero
        • Waste management
        • Water
    • Digital services and solutions
      • What We Do
        • Cyber Security Services
        • Daisy
        • Data science advisory solutions
        • Digital and data advisory services
        • Digital solutions for water
        • Digital transport planning
        • How to net zero
        • Kit of parts
    • Planning and development
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Environmental assessment and management
        • How to net zero
        • Infrastructure planning and consulting
        • Land referencing and land assembly
        • Landscape architecture
        • Local government
        • Placemaking development and urban regeneration
        • Stakeholder engagement and strategic communications
        • Town planning and consulting
        • Transport planning
        • Urban planning and design
    • Energy
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Energy transition
        • How to net zero
        • Hydrogen energy
        • Nuclear energy
        • Offshore wind
        • Solar energy
    • Water
      • What We Do
        • Asset management for water
        • Desalination
        • Digital solutions for water
        • Drinking water supply
        • How to net zero
        • Industrial water
        • Minewater management
        • Nature based solutions
        • Storm water and flood risk management
        • Wastewater treatment
        • Water infrastructure
        • Water planning and advisory
        • Water resources
    • Advisory
      • What We Do
      • Expertise at your service
        • Asset management
        • Data Science Advisory Solutions
        • Digital advisory
        • Economics
        • ESG strategy
        • How to net zero
        • Investor and lenders advisory
        • Net zero and sustainability advisory
        • Project, programme and commercial management
        • Public private partnerships and capital investment
        • Transformation and change management
  • Insights
    • Climate
    • Mobility
    • Places
    • Resources
    • Society
    • Technology
    • Meet our Changemakers
  • Careers
    • Job opportunities
    • Early Career
    • Experienced Professionals
    • Why join us?
Select your language and location

We are locally dedicated with international scale.

International
  • Global
    English — Français
Americas
  • Brazil
    Português
  • Canada
    English — Français
  • Chile
    Español
  • Colombia
    Español
  • Mexico
    Español
  • Panama
    Español
  • Peru
    Español
  • United States
    English
Africa
  • South Africa
    English
Asia
  • China
    中文(简体) — English
  • Hong Kong
    English
  • India
    English
  • Indonesia
    English
  • Malaysia
    English
  • Philippines
    English
  • Singapore
    English
  • South Korea
    한국어(대한민국) — English
  • Thailand
    English
Europe
  • Denmark
    Dansk
  • Finland
    Suomi
  • France
    Français
  • Germany
    Deutsch
  • Hungary
    English
  • Italy
    Italiano
  • Netherlands
    Nederlands
  • Norway
    Norsk
  • Poland
    Polski
  • Romania
    English
  • Spain
    Español
  • Sweden
    Svenska
  • Switzerland
    Deutsch — Français
  • Turkey
    Turkish
  • United Kingdom
    English
Middle East
  • Kuwait
    English
  • Oman
    English
  • Qatar
    English
  • Saudi Arabia
    English
  • United Arab Emirates
    English
Oceania
  • Australia
    English
  • New Zealand
    English
Worldwide offices
    • Investors
      Discover our diverse business, financial results and strategic ambitions.

      We are committed to delivering sustainable value to our shareholders and exceptional professional services to our clients.

      Find out more
      Investors
      • Corporate governance
      • Press releases
      • Reports and filings
      • Stock information
      • Shareholder information
      • Presentations and events
      Corporate governance
      • Audit committee
      • Board of directors
      • Business Conduct Hotline
      • Constating documents
      • Governance documents
      • Governance ethics and compensation committee
      • Mandates
      Reports and filings
      • AIF
      • Annual
      • Information circular
      • Quarterly
      • SEDAR+ filings
      • Sustainability
      Stock information
      • Analyst coverage
      Shareholder information
      • Acquisitions
      • Dividends
      • FAQ
      Featured content
      Thn-Web-IR-2025-Q1-Results
      WSP's Q1 2025 Results

      We released our 2025 first quarter results on May 7, 2025 after market close.

    • Investors
      • Corporate governance
        • Investors
        • Corporate Governance
          • Audit committee
          • Board of directors
          • Business Conduct Hotline
          • Constating documents
          • Governance documents
          • Governance ethics and compensation committee
          • Mandates
      • Press releases
      • Reports and filings
        • Investors
        • REPORTS & FILINGS
          • AIF
          • Annual
          • Information circular
          • Quarterly
          • SEDAR+ filings
          • Sustainability
      • Stock information
        • Investors
        • Stock Information
          • Analyst coverage
      • Shareholder information
        • Investors
        • Shareholder Information
          • Acquisitions
          • Dividends
          • Drip
          • FAQ
      • Presentations and events
    • News
      Progress happens quickly.

      Stay up to date with our projects, news, events and more.

      News
      • Latest news
      • WSP in the media
      • Our Awards
      • Events and webinars
      Featured content
      our-awards-thumbnail-image (1)
      Award Winning Engineering and Project Management

    • Contact us
      We are dedicated to our local communities and driven by global talent.

      We solve problems for our clients and the communities we serve, meeting the needs of today and tomorrow’s challenges. Contact us to find out how we…

      Contact Us

      Follow us

      Contact us
      • Request a proposal
      • Send a message
      • Find an expert
      • Offices
    • Investors
      Discover our diverse business, financial results and strategic ambitions.

      We are committed to delivering sustainable value to our shareholders and exceptional professional services to our clients.

      Find out more
      Investors
      • Corporate governance
      • Press releases
      • Reports and filings
      • Stock information
      • Shareholder information
      • Presentations and events
      Corporate governance
      • Audit committee
      • Board of directors
      • Business Conduct Hotline
      • Constating documents
      • Governance documents
      • Governance ethics and compensation committee
      • Mandates
      Reports and filings
      • AIF
      • Annual
      • Information circular
      • Quarterly
      • SEDAR+ filings
      • Sustainability
      Stock information
      • Analyst coverage
      Shareholder information
      • Acquisitions
      • Dividends
      • FAQ
      Featured content
      Thn-Web-IR-2025-Q1-Results
      WSP's Q1 2025 Results

      We released our 2025 first quarter results on May 7, 2025 after market close.

    • Investors
      • Corporate governance
        • Investors
        • Corporate Governance
          • Audit committee
          • Board of directors
          • Business Conduct Hotline
          • Constating documents
          • Governance documents
          • Governance ethics and compensation committee
          • Mandates
      • Press releases
      • Reports and filings
        • Investors
        • REPORTS & FILINGS
          • AIF
          • Annual
          • Information circular
          • Quarterly
          • SEDAR+ filings
          • Sustainability
      • Stock information
        • Investors
        • Stock Information
          • Analyst coverage
      • Shareholder information
        • Investors
        • Shareholder Information
          • Acquisitions
          • Dividends
          • Drip
          • FAQ
      • Presentations and events
    • News
      • Latest news
      • WSP in the media
      • Our Awards
      • Events and webinars
    • Contact us
      • Request a proposal
      • Send a message
      • Find an expert
      • Offices
Retrofit rebuild lens

Why it’s (Almost) Always Better
to Retrofit than Rebuild

How to build net-zero is the wrong question, says WSP structural engineer Mahdi Babaee –
we should be asking how to build as little as possible

Retrofit rebuild lens

Why it’s (Almost) Always Better
to Retrofit than Rebuild

How to build net-zero is the wrong question, says WSP structural engineer Mahdi Babaee –
we should be asking how to build as little as possible

  1. We are WSP
  2. Insights
  3. Why it’s (Almost) Always Better to Retrofit than Rebuild
map marker Global | 12 June 2024
Reading Time : 5 minutes

Is it always better to retrofit than rebuild, from a carbon point of view?

As a structural engineer trying to design a new zero-carbon building, you quickly realize that no matter what you do – specifying low-carbon materials, optimizing the structure – it’s difficult, if not impossible, to reach zero without some form of carbon offsetting, at least with the current rate of grid decarbonization and the availability of renewable energy.

Obviously, the best option is not to build anything, but retrofitting existing structures is a middle ground. That can save a substantial amount of carbon emissions compared to new-build structures. I think that’s the path forward for the construction industry, particularly the commercial sector.
 

Are there any exceptions, when a new-build would be lower carbon than a retrofit?

There are questions about how efficient the existing building is, but that’s almost always related to operational carbon – if there’s an inefficient ventilation system, you can change it. There could be very rare cases where a structure is near to end of life – for instance, in a coastal zone where there’s active corrosion, or where the existing grid or floor-to-floor height significantly compromises future viability. There, it could make sense to build a new structure rather than expending significant resources to strengthen or adapt the existing one, which would also be carbon-intensive.
 

So there would have to be a need for new structural materials? Operational carbon alone could never sway the balance?

Exactly. If you have a building that is operationally very inefficient – let’s say it has a particular orientation that doesn’t get any sunlight, so it always takes a lot of energy and therefore operational carbon to keep the building warm. In the short term, you might wonder if it’s worth building a new building. But as the electricity grid decarbonizes, that operational carbon will fall, and continue to fall, so that in 20-30 years time, it’s very small. So that justification for building something new based on operational carbon savings won’t necessarily be the same in 10-20 years.
 

What about the embodied carbon of retrofitting itself?

When you refurbish a structure, there is always an interaction between the embodied carbon in the structural materials that you’re adding or replacing, and the operational carbon of the building. Let’s say you’re adding storeys on top of an existing building. As a structural engineer, you would typically choose the lightest system to reduce the embodied carbon as far as possible. But if it doesn’t have good insulation and thermal properties, that could increase the operational energy needed for heating and cooling, and therefore the operational carbon. So you might go with a thicker element and investigate more carbon-intensive concrete options, or you need to add more insulation.

But over a 20-30 year service life, you would still be saving on operational carbon. It's not a linear, straightforward problem, it’s an optimization problem. That’s why a good retrofit is multidisciplinary, involving collaboration between the architect, the structural engineer and the building services team to assess the whole-life carbon of a range of options.
 

How much difference could low-carbon materials make to the equation?

There is a lot of conversations around low-carbon materials in the industry nowadays, and it indirectly promotes the idea that design can be business-as-usual – that a structural engineer will come in at the end of the decision-making process and introduce a low-carbon material that saves the day. That’s passive decarbonization. Even if we magically come up with a concrete that has zero embodied carbon, we are still consuming the planet’s finite resources, with negative impacts to biodiversity and air quality from mineral extraction, transportation and manufacturing. There is always some sort of emission. So I don’t think that using a low-carbon alternative is a good justification for excessive use of materials.
 

So what should we do instead? What would active decarbonization look like?

The conversation should be about low-carbon strategies, not just materials, and we need to think about it from the get-go. For instance, if a developer wants to build two 20-storey towers, do they really need to do that? Could we retrofit the existing structure on the site, retain the basements and podium levels and add levels on top?

If there is a case for building a structure, the rule of thumb is that the closer the column space, the thinner the slabs, and the lower the overall embodied carbon, because the slabs are the most carbon-intensive of all structural elements. A WSP study found that for a typical car park building, increasing the span from 8m to 10m increases the embodied carbon by 25-30%. Typically, architects and developers want to have larger spans, but maybe now we need to think about integrating more columns. And more columns could mean that you lose car parking spaces, and that might mean lost revenue for the developer. So all of these conversations need to happen at the very beginning, and be supported by carbon-centric optioneering studies.

To give a numerical perspective, if we specify the best low-carbon concrete currently available in the market, we can save on average up to 20-25% of the embodied carbon. But if we could play with the column spacing at the beginning, that could save another 20-30%. So active decarbonization means not leaving it to material replacement. Think about reuse, think about changing the design – and think about not building at all.

  • Mahdi Babaee is a technical director and national net-zero lead (structures) at WSP in Australia 
prf-mahdi-babaee
Mahdi Babaee
Australia

Share this page

  • Share on Facebook - Warning, this link will open a new tab.
  • Share on Linkedin - Warning, this link will open a new tab.
  • Share on Twitter - Warning, this link will open a new tab.
  • Share on Skype - Warning, this link will open your Skype application.

Related themes and tags

  • Decarbonization (91)


  • Buildings (42)

More on this subject

Procurement-Paradigm-Thumb

July 2025

Procurement Paradigms: Reflections on collaborative approaches for tunnels and underground construction projects

Global
svg-icon White Paper
Decarbonization , Mobility
thn-Airport Master Planning

July 2025

Enhancing Airport Master Planning in Latin America

Global
svg-icon White Paper
Decarbonization , Mobility , Resilience , Technology
Low Carbon

June 2025 | 6 minutes

Low-carbon strategies to Improve neighbourhood safety

Global
svg-icon Feature
Decarbonization , Places
thn-Advancing-Electrifications-Role-in-our-Energy-Systems

May 2025 | 5:22 minutes

Advancing Electrification’s Role in our Energy Systems

United States
svg-icon Feature
Resilience , Climate , Energy Transition , Decarbonization
thumbnail-asset-management-energy-transition

May 2025

Advancing Energy Transition? Count Your Assets Too!

svg-icon Feature
Decarbonization , Energy Transition , Resilience
thn-thermal-energy-networks-2

May 2025 | 4:00 minutes

Perfect TENs

United States
svg-icon Feature
Decarbonization , Energy Transition , Resilience
Regenerative design 4

April 2025 | 6 min

Regenerative design: Thinking beyond sustainability

United Kingdom
svg-icon Feature
Decarbonization
TOD-2-WP-Thumbnail

March 2025

Transit-Oriented Communities Advance Sustainable Cities

Global
svg-icon White Paper
Decarbonization , Energy Transition , Mobility , Places , Resilience , Society , Technology
Img-Bridge-Data-Thumb

March 2025

Accessing the Right Data to Reduce Carbon in Bridge Design

Global
svg-icon Feature
Decarbonization
Img-Planning-Paradox-Thumb

March 2025

Navigating the Built Environment Planning Paradox

Global
svg-icon Feature
Climate , Decarbonization , Energy Transition , Mobility , Places , Resilience , Resources , Society , Technology
thn-website-insights-tfnd-essentials

January 2025

TNFD Essentials: A Beginner’s Guide to Nature-Related Financial Disclosures

Canada
svg-icon Feature
Decarbonization
thn-Eric-QA-7

November 2024

Public Transport Drives Sustainable Communities

Global
svg-icon Feature
Decarbonization , Mobility , Society
  •  
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  •   Page will open in a new tab
  • Who We Are
  • Our story
  • Future Ready
  • UK and Ireland leadership
  • Our offices
  • What We Do
  • Sectors
  • Services
  • Projects
  • Insights
  • Climate
  • Mobility
  • Places
  • Society
  • Resources
  • Technology
  • Careers
  • Job opportunities
  • Early career
  • Experienced professionals
  • Why join us?
  • Corporate
  • Policies
  • Sustainability
  • Health and safety
  • Investors
  • Business Conduct Hotline
  • News
  • Corporate governance
  • Ethics and integrity
    ©2025 WSP
    • The WSP logo
    • Privacy notice
    • Anti-spam commitment
    • UK corporate governance statement
    • UK policies
    • Cookie notice
    • Terms of use
    • Supplying to WSP
    ©2025 WSP
    Exiting our Website

    You are about to leave WSP.com and are being redirected to a job opportunity at Louis Berger, which has been recently acquired by WSP in the US.